top of page

The Poppy and the Musical

5 days ago
5 min read

The cast of All Is Calm from the PBS broadcast


Welcome to this week’s edition of Summit Stages News! I’m Rebecca Burnham and this is where you get weekly updates about musical theatre that promotes wholeness and belonging; learn about visionary creators, producers and others; and discover some mighty stories that need to be turned into musicals.


I’m on a collaborative mission to give cynics reason to become connectors, drifters hope to become builders, and enemies understanding to become friends, all through musical theatre. It’s a task that’s way bigger than I am and this newsletter is my effort to gather with people of vision, heart, and skills so we can do that work together.


Today, I’m writing about All is Calm, a documusical about the Christmas Truce of 1914, in honour of Remembrance Day.


Yesterday, November 11, was a statutory holiday in Canada, set aside to remember our veterans and, more especially, those who didn’t come home from war. We celebrate each year with memorial ceremonies at the cenotaph – a monument inscribed with the names of local men and boys who gave their lives for their nation. We wear poppies over our hearts, observe a minute of silence at 11am, and somebody reads or sings John McCrae’s poetic lament, “In Flander’s Fields,” which most of us learned by heart in elementary school. It ends with a charge from the fallen to the living:


“Take up our quarrel with the foe:


To you from failing hands we throw


The torch; be yours to hold it high.


If ye break faith with us who die


We shall not sleep, though poppies grow


In Flanders Fields.”


A Remembrance Day Flag


I don’t think I can read those lines without a stirring of the heart, not in sympathy with warfare, but in determined resolution to build peace. True, the WWI poet was a Canadian soldier and surgeon, fighting as part of the Allied Powers against the Central Powers. He believed he was fighting for liberty. Maybe he was thinking of the Germans in the trenches across from him when he wrote “the foe.” But I’ve never understood it that way. I’ve always been taught that the foe we quarrel with is tyranny, apathy, and everything else that would destroy our powers of peaceful self-government. I have learned that “the foe” includes the dehumanization of people on the other side of an issue, upon which a devastating conflict of more than four years, that claimed 15-22 million lives, depended. That’s what I think of when I see a poppy alongside the slogan, “Lest We Forget.”




That is why I rejoiced yesterday morning, when I came home from my night job to find my family in the living room watching the famous Sainsbury’s ad about the Christmas Truce of 1914. And it’s why my thoughts were turned to Peter Rothstein’s docu-musical All Is Calm that portrays the story with traditional carols in rich, acapella harmonies (arranged by Erick Lichte & Timothy C. Takach) with dialogue taken directly from letters and journals of the soldiers involved, plus official wartime documents. I was deeply moved by the show when it toured to my area in 2019. And I was moved again yesterday when I explored Mr. Rothstein’s reasons for writing it.


Although he’d studied WWI in high school and college, he’d never learned about this historical event. When he eventually encountered the story, he warmed to the type of heroism it shows us, something very different from what’s expressed in the propaganda of warfare. “I believe these men who exercised peace that day were heroic, yet their names never ended up in history books,” he explains. “That day, it took a lot more courage to exercise peace than to exercise war and I want their names to be said out loud; I want them to have their rightful place in history.”


How did it happen? As Christmas approached, the soldiers on both sides started singing carols, back and forth, from the cover of the trenches. Then, according to legend, a German soldier climbed out into the line of fire, stepped into no man’s land, and started singing “Stille Nacht” (Silent Night).


During rehearsals, Mr. Rothstein, who directed the award-winning 2018 off-Broadway run, would ask the cast to pause and think about the courage of that moment when the first soldier ventured into No Man’s Land. “He was trusting that his enemy was not going to fire…” Despite all the resentments for loved ones lost that are endemic to war, “he’s trusting that that enemy is going to choose peace at that moment. And not only that one enemy, the hundreds of men along the front line. He’s trusting that not one of them is going to fire.”

Learning from that courage matters because we’re living in a time of extraordinary division, where we’re inclined to see our neighbours as our enemies. “I can’t imagine that we can’t somehow see beyond our divisiveness if we look at this moment in history where these men chose trust, chose hope, chose peace. We can do the same. I have to believe that,” he says.


The longing to tell a story that helps us see beyond enemy labels is what inspired him to book a flight to the Western Front for research in March 2003, the night that the US invaded Iraq. He struggled to figure out how to portray it compellingly, because the climax is peace, not conflict. He decided to use the actual words of those who participated, rather than create fictional characters, trusting that their authenticity would bring the story home. And it debuted in 2007 as a radio play, because the medium would have been familiar to the soldiers the story is about. It was so successful that it was eventually staged off-Broadway and has been broadcast on five continents and performed in 30 US states, Canada, Australia and Europe. It returns under Mr. Rothstein’s direction to Theater Latté Da, in Minneapolis, where he is the founding artistic director. It is also available for licensing through Concord Theatricals.


Mr. Rothstein says, “I believe music is what instigated the Christmas truce.” I love that thought for many reasons. And I suspect there was something more. I’ve tried to imagine myself in a trench on that brutal Christmas Eve of 1914. I imagine the singing of Christmas carols by believers in Jesus Christ, filling the trenches with the Christmas spirit. I believe in a Divine Being who cares deeply about all His children, regardless of ethnicity, faith, culture, or other dividing label; and who is deeply grieved by war.


I imagine the soldier who first left the trenches was not the only one so prompted by the sweet, persuasive spirit of that Divine Being. I suspect that when one man had the courage to follow those promptings, there was a collective sigh of relief as others became emboldened to heed the internal call they were, themselves feeling, and join in exercising trust and peace.


I don’t think the Christmas miracle depended on the participants being Christians. Not in any way. There is a remarkable story about a Muslim sultan creating peace with Christian invaders, that brought about an end to the Crusades, which also needs to be brought to the stage. But I was thinking this morning about where I would be (afraid, angry, and mostly hopeless) without the belief that God cares and the work of peace is the work of God. I feel a need to acknowledge that, as I end this post.


All Is Calm is a musical unlike anything you are likely to have ever seen. It’s available for viewing on PBS, and I expect it to become a treasured new November-December tradition for my family.

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

© 2024 by Summit Stages. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page